Scroll Top

The Differences Between Insurance Companies, Agents and Brokers

The Differences Between Insurance Companies, Agents and Brokers

Insurance companies, agents, and brokers are not the same. Don’t be alarmed if this is new to you. Consumers often have misconceptions about these differences. If you are looking for insurance, it is important to know the differences between agents, companies and brokers. This will help you choose the right provider for your needs.

What is an insurance company?

What is an insurance company and what are they? Insurance companies provide coverage to consumers and businesses in order to protect them against the cost of accidents and natural disasters. Insurance companies will determine the level of risk for an individual or business and charge them a premium according to that risk. If you live in a region prone to wildfires, for example, you might pay a premium to insure your house.

Insurance companies have the following roles:

  • Issue policies
  • Insurance coverage requires financial support
  • Claims for payment

The insurance company will charge you a premium for your policy and, if an insured event causes you damage, it will pay you the agreed upon amount. Insurance companies have been designed to make a profit and pay out the agreed-upon amounts. If an insurance company receives a surplus from premiums it can safely invest the money to generate income.

Insurance Agency vs. Company

What’s the difference between a company and an agent? What is the difference between an insurance company, and a broker or agent? Insurance agents and brokers are simply intermediaries who act as a link between the companies and their customers. A company of insurance appoints a number of insurance agencies. Insurance companies provide the product while agencies offer the service of distributing it to the consumer.

Fassbender Insurance CTA

Pros and Cons of an Insurance Company

What are the advantages and disadvantages of an insurance company?


One of the biggest benefits of using an insurance provider is that you can get a variety of coverage.

  • Direct provider: The insurance company provides the insurance policy. You can purchase an insurance policy directly from the company if you do not want to deal with middlemen.


Cons of using an insurance provider include:

  • Service impersonal: Insurance companies do not provide the same individualized service that an agent or broker can. You may prefer to work with a broker or agent if you’re looking for someone to take your needs into account.
  • Options are limited: If you purchase insurance through a single company, your options are restricted to what they offer.

What is an Insurance Agency?

What are insurance agents? These agents have traditionally represented an insurance company, or several insurance companies, to the public. Agents provide information to insurance buyers about the options and products offered by different companies. You can choose the insurance policies and options that you want through your agent.

Insurance agents are responsible for:

  • Assist in the process of transferring insurance between insurers and insurance buyers.
  • Find the best insurance options for their clients.
  • Find the best rates of premium for a customer.

Agents have a contractual obligation to provide policies and contracts which meet certain guidelines. These guidelines are determined by contractual agreements between insurance companies and insurance agents.

Agents are either captive agents or independent. Captive agents are only affiliated with one insurance company, while independent agents work for multiple companies. Independent agents compare policies across multiple carriers to find you the best options and terms.

Broker vs. Insurance Agent Broker vs. Insurance Agent

What is the distinction between an insurance broker and agent? Both agents and brokers represent insurance companies as well as insurance buyers. However, their roles during the buying process are different. Insurance agents represent the insurance companies they work with while insurance brokers represent the insurance buyers.

insurance agency

Pros and Cons of an Insurance Agency

What are the advantages and disadvantages of an insurance agency?


Why use an independent agent for insurance? Choose an independent insurance agent for the following benefits:

  • Attention individualized: Because an agency is smaller than an insurer, you’ll receive more attention individualized.
  • Independent agents can offer you a better policy: They compare the policies of different insurers to find you the most suitable policy.
  • There is no cost to you: Working with an insurance agent does not require that you pay an hourly rate or a consultation fee. The same price applies whether you buy your insurance policy from an agent or directly through the company.


Cons of using an insurance agency include:

  • Independent agencies receive less support because they don’t represent a single insurance company. Insurance agencies may have limited options.

What is an insurance broker?

What is an insurance broker? Insurance brokers have traditionally represented the public before insurance companies. Brokers are experts in risk management and the insurance industry and serve as intermediaries for insurance companies and buyers.

Brokers can help their customers by:

  • Selecting the carrier
  • Selecting the right coverage
  • Pricing
  • Arrange financing

Who do insurance brokers represent exactly? Insurance brokers are the advocates of insurance buyers. They will use their expertise and knowledge to evaluate your situation, and make sure your policy meets your insurance needs.

Brokers represent consumers, while agents represent insurance companies. Brokers are unbiased because they don’t represent any companies.

The pros and cons of working with an insurance broker

What are the advantages and disadvantages of working with an insurance broker?


There are many benefits to choosing an insurance broker.

  • Brokers are honest and act in their clients’ best interests. A broker will represent you, not a particular insurance company. You can be assured that you’ll receive unbiased advice and recommendations. A broker will also provide full disclosure of their broker fees and commission rates.
  • Knowledge on many topics: Insurance brokers are well-versed in the options and rates offered by different insurance companies, as well as the industry.
  • Brokers can offer better prices: Since a broker doesn’t have to sell a specific insurance company’s product, he or she is able to provide you with multiple insurance options and negotiate the best terms.


What are the cons of using an insurance broker? Cons of using an insurance agency include:

  • Brokers generally get paid on a commission basis, which may influence the policies that they recommend.
  • The quality of services varies from brokerage to brokerage: You may want to compare the different brokerages before selecting one.

When choosing an insurer, consider the pros and cons associated with working with an agent.